Skip to main content

Site Search:

  • Home
  • Third Place: “Insight on the Heart of Mediation” by Anna Doyle

Prologue

The ancient Celtic Goddess Ériu rejoiced in creating abundance and plentitude for her people. Her island, Éire, was majestic and fruitful and her rivers and seas ran crystal clear. Sadly, down through millennia, there came war, famine, conflict and colonisation, with many children leaving her shores. Those who remained struggled but were courageous and determined to aspire to a life of peace, dignity and inclusion. The long and challenging road to peace also gave them a precious gift – a deep insight into conflict resolution.

In the mid-20th century, Ériu entrusted a mission of peacemaking to Maura Wall Murphy. She called her to help create a process of mediation whereby people might be placed at the heart of key decision-making processes, moving from the periphery of third-party decisions that disempowered them, to the very centre of self-driven processes that enabled them.

Ériu now holds her breath and ponders:

  • “Will mediators on the island of Éire :
  • Bravely take to the sky like a murmuration of starlings?
  • Change shape in unison to form new images that spark creative imagination?
  • Afford themselves, and others, protection from the threats of predators? and
  • Come to nest peacefully in celestial space and transform conflict?“

Time will tell.

The story, so far, resonates through the words of Catherine Kelly Ali & Anna Walsh Doyle.

Part One

Introduction

Maura Wall Murphy was born in Limerick, Éire (Ireland) in 1931. Her early memories of growing up in the 1940’s, between two World Wars, echoed the struggle of an emerging nation exploring ways of forging an independent being. Maura had an intuitive sense of time and place guiding her life – as a child in Limerick, through the 17 years she spent as a nun working with medical missionaries in Africa, then consciously awakening with the civil rights movement in the US, inspiring her to take a new pathway. Along this journey, Maura tuned into the pressing needs of her time and responded by becoming a true pioneer of mediation.

Sources of inspiration

Maura was alert from an early age to absorbing the influence of those around her. Her faith in life and her willingness to serve her country were inspired by her father, who nurtured her strong sense of justice and power, as well as a love for land and country and the capacity to make deep and lasting connections. She drew inspiration too from her mother, a practical social worker with a sense of community and sacrifice, who encouraged women to take charge of their lives. Maura wanted to discover her authentic voice. She was also inspired by the religious work of Mary Martin and had seen a film at school showing her work in a leprosy settlement.
Mary Martin was the eldest of 12 children and her father, T.M. Martin came from a wealthy catholic family in Dublin. In 1921, Queen Victoria was on the throne and Mary’s brothers were in the British army. She decided to go to Nigeria with two other women and got permission from the bishop. In those days, religious women were not allowed to practice medicine, but Church thinking changed in 1937. Mary trained as a midwife in Holles Street Maternity Hospital and got permission to start a religious community with five other women. In 1937, she opened a religious house in Drogheda with a vision to educate and to build an international hospital. She believed that you cannot educate people when they are fighting for survival; first, you must help them to live better lives, rear their children and establish the next generation.

Two callings – rooted and founded in love

Mary Martin’s visionary work was “rooted and founded in love” and Maura wanted her life’s work to echo this principle. Her first calling was to missionary work and she entered the Medical Missionaries of Mary community in Clonmel in 1951. As Sister Victoire, Maura did social work in Drogheda in the 1960’s and went on to work in Africa in the leprosy settlements and the university hospital, where she also delighted in driving a truck!

She came back to Ireland in 1965, getting a scholarship in 1966. From 1966 to 1968, Maura moved to America where she did a Master’s degree in social work at Boston College. This was a hugely formative period of her life, witnessing the civil rights marches and sadly hearing of the shooting of Dr Martin Luther King live on radio. Consciously awakened by the experience, she emerged with a new sense of empowerment, ready to contribute. Trusting her intuition and inner voice, Maura went back to the missions in 1968 but finally left the missionary community in 1969.

At the tender age of 36, after seventeen years of religious life and work, Maura set out to get a job and find a place to live. She started off earning 50 pounds a month as a social worker and rented a flat with a family in Sandymount. As she was carving out her new life, a second calling came her way to also be ‘rooted and founded in love’. She met Denston Murphy, the love of her life, in 1971, he having left the religious order of Dominicans. Maura and Denston were married in December 1975 at Coleraine Registry Office. She commuted from Coleraine, taking a job in Queens University, Belfast from 1976 to 1978 and eventually, moved to Dublin in 1979 to enjoy their new life together.

From self to community

There was a slow acknowledgement in Ireland in the late sixties and early seventies that not all marriages last. There was no provision in the 1937 Irish Constitution for separating couples or for divorce and there was a constitutional ban on the dissolution of marriage. A possible exit strategy from a failed marriage was to seek a Catholic Church annulment under canon law, but this did not allow remarriage in the eyes of the state. Irish marriage was for life, for better or worse and this brought deep, silent suffering for many couples, especially for the children.

The plight of deserted wives became one of five demands that the Irish Women’s Liberation Movement took up in their 1970 report. In 1972, the late Nuala Fennell and others founded an organisation called AIM (Action, Information, Motivation) which acted as a pressure group to change and reform the law on marital breakdown.

When the Family Home Protection Act 1976 was enacted, this meant that the family home could not be sold without the consent of both spouses. In addition, the Family Home (Maintenance of Spouses and Children) Act 1976 gave a statutory right to maintenance to the spouse and the children. Up to that point, most family rights were vested in the husband and Irish wives had little legal remedy against either unfair treatment or domestic violence.

Around this time, social workers like Maura became increasingly concerned about the effects of marriage breakdown on children. Research showed that children adjusted best to separation where both parents were able to provide some continuous stability and love as the couple’s relationships transitioned. Maura was a family therapist at St. John of God, Orwell Road, Dublin and wanted to influence positive change in these family transitions.

Pivotal moments for mediation

In 1983, Maura became the chair of the Marriage Counselling Service (MSC) and, in its 21st year, she invited the renowned Dr John Haynes from New York to speak about family mediation at the MCS annual conference in October 1983, a pivotal moment for mediation.

Fortunately, a new kind of political support for social change was also emerging. Initiatives that might have been stifled in the past were now finding voice. The people of Ireland wanted to shake off the shackles of an oppressive past and this was finding expression and gaining ground. From 1982 to 1986, Nuala Fennell TD was appointed as the first Minister of State for Women’s Affairs at the Department of the Taoiseach with responsibility for Family Law Reform at the Department of Justice. She was inspired to ask Maura to take on the challenge of introducing ‘conciliation’ (later renamed as ‘mediation’) to support separating couples and Maura rose to the challenge.

In October 1983, Barry Desmond TD, Minister for Health spoke about the need for divorce in Ireland and called for the establishment of a mediation service. An all-party Joint Oireachtas Committee on Marital Breakdown was set up to examine the constitutional prohibition on divorce and the then existing laws on civil nullity.

In 1984, Minister Fennell organised a seminar to promote discussion around the introduction of a more informal approach to marriage breakdown. In 1985, she appointed a Steering Committee to draw up arrangements for a pilot family conciliation scheme. Maura was one of the members of this Committee (and remained so until the post of Co-ordinator of the service was later advertised). The main inspiration of the work of this committee was the concept of empowerment – seeking to put control of the dispute back into the hands of the disputants, by empowering them to work out a resolution themselves, with the assistance of a neutral third-party mediator.

In 1985, Dr John Haynes was invited back to Dublin to present the first professional training course in family mediation for 20 people. This was a turning point and led to the introduction of an “all issues” approach that was adopted when the Family Mediation Service was formed.

Family Mediation Service launched

The Family Mediation Scheme in the Republic of Ireland was officially launched in July 1986 by Minister Fennell, providing a free professional and confidential service to couples who wanted to negotiate together the arrangements for living apart. It was a community-based out of court mediation model that had been designed by the Steering Committee and was later recognised as a model scheme in Britain and Northern Ireland.

In September 1986, The Family Mediation Service (FMS) opened its doors to clients as a three-year pilot scheme under the Department of Justice with Maura Wall Murphy as the Coordinator. When the pilot came to an end in 1989, there was an expectation that the service would be put on a permanent footing and expanded nationwide, but this did not happen immediately. The FMS held a one-day conference in 1988 to report progress but the momentum for change had fallen away with the political changes that had taken place in the interim. Nevertheless, the Steering Committee, under the continuing chairmanship of Jim Higgins, did not lose its vision and provided valued stewardship, keeping the reporting lines open with the Department of Justice.

In 1989, the Judicial Separation and Family Law Reform Bill created a path to court for a judge to determine the separation arrangements for those who could not arrive at a voluntary, private legal separation.

The tide had turned

Building on this earlier success, an inter-departmental review group on marital breakdown reported to the Minister for Justice in autumn 1992 in the form of a White Paper. At that point, the Government formally recognised the success of the mediation services and initiated a review to determine the nature of appropriate long-term mediation services.

In 1993, the FMS was transferred from the Department of Justice to the Department of Equality and Law Reform in order to support the Government’s commitment to introducing divorce. Minister Mervyn Taylor announced in the Dáil that he would put the FMS on a permanent statutory basis; but it would take another ten years for this to happen.

A second divorce referendum was carried out in November 1995, resulting in the introduction in Ireland of The Family Law Divorce Act 1996. That year, the first FMS regional office opened in Limerick as the initial service outside Dublin, followed by Cork in 1998, and Galway in 1999. The FMS became established in 16 centres, nationwide.

In 1996, Maura retired as Service Coordinator having served with the FMS for 10 years. In 1998, the FMS moved to a reconstituted Department of Social, Community and Family Affairs. Then, in 2003 the Family Support Agency (FSA) Act 2001, enabled FMS to become established as a statutory body. The FMS had realised the vision of its founders—to put in place a nationwide, publicly funded, free mediation service, operating in four regional full-time centres – Dublin, Cork, Galway and Limerick and twelve part-time offices.

State infrastructure realigns

In 2011, three state agencies – Courts Service, Legal Aid Board and FMS – received sanction from Department of Finance to provide mediation information meetings at the Family District Court in Dublin’s Temple Bar for applicants seeking custody and access, maintenance and guardianship orders. FMS then opened a mediation service in Dolphin House.

Minister Alan Shatter brought the FMS back to the Department of Justice in May 2011 and, in October that year, it was integrated into the Legal Aid Board, where it remains to this day. The long-standing Family Mediation Service training programme which was delivered since 1997 to mediators who wished to specialise in the field was accredited to the National University Maynooth and the new programme began in 2011. Finally, the Mediation Act came into being in 2017 and is the basis for the settlement of disputes by mediation in Ireland today. It also provides for the establishment of a body to be known as the Mediation Council of Ireland, overseeing the conduct of the profession of mediator and promoting public awareness of the value of mediation (this has yet to be set up).

Inspiring others

In the 1990’s, apart from mediation, Maura was also busy getting on with her life. She and Denston finally got married with the blessing of the Church in 1991, looking forward to sharing their lives and hopes together.

In an Ireland that was then struggling to forge its own identity and bring about social revolution, Maura had paved the way for new thinking in the 1980’s leading to the creation of the first Family Mediation Service, long before divorce could even be spoken of. A strong emphasis was placed on the children of a marriage, the aim being to have the parents discuss and agree on decisions about guardianship before separation, with the help of a professional mediator. Acutely aware of her power to influence life and work for the good, her love of learning and keen social awareness drove her forward fearlessly, with steely determination, sound purpose and insightful vision. Maura was a visionary woman, always seeking to piece fragments of life together in a search for meaning, inspiring a new generation to embrace their deeper calling.

Honouring a visionary

The Mediators’ Institute of Ireland honoured Maura Wall Murphy on 4th November 2011 with an award for her contribution to the vision and development of mediation in Ireland, also recognising the adoption of its principles in the genuine belief that to use mediation, and to model behaviour, would lead to a better way forward for Mediators, organisations and for the parties in conflict.

On the occasion of Maura’s 90th birthday, she was delighted to receive a letter of commendation from President Michael D. Higgins for her pioneering work in mediation. She also received a tribute from Ken Cloke, world-renowned author and founder of Mediators Beyond Borders, who wrote: “Please give Maura my love and tell her that I have very fond memories of her and the brief times we spent together. She was a pioneer, and I bow to her.”

Sadly, Maura died on 6th March, 2024 but her legacy lives on, as a mother of mediation.

Part Two

– Maura’s story resonates through Catherine –

Early Influences of Maura

Under the counter of my grandmother, Minnie Wall’s classy drapery shop, there were two large black and white hand-made photo albums. Deckled pictures, held in place by four black envelope corners, each had a description underneath in beautiful, even calligraphy; the pencil lines had not been erased. Naples, Pisa, Florence, Rome were the main cities. I poured over each small picture and imagined my view of the world. The second album captured moments of my parents’ courtship and marriage. Romantic floral artwork on the capital J for Jeremiah and G for Gobnait, mirrored a child’s admiration for the stylish, dignified identities encapsulated in the names of my parents.

Decades later, in Boston College, I wondered at the famous stained-glass windows and connected with a lady-monk-scribe, quill pen in hand, the power of the word firing up her spine and mind, her muse holding the space for creative energy, while another showered her soul work. The power of the word, awakened by calligraphic art, had moved to mediation alchemy; Maura’s influence on my life.

In Trinidad

Trinidad, a post-colonial island, was oil-rich and developing rapidly and unevenly, experiencing booms and bursts. Institutions passed seamlessly from colonial days to republic days leaving exclusion, inequality and injustice intact. Historic trauma remained unaddressed; brutal violence and white-collar corruption was, and is, commonplace. Trinis are highly creative people yet paradoxically, culture and politics failed to support vulnerable groups. Social development projects often became stuck, despite the huge sums of money invested in them. The criminal justice system pushed people down and out of society, thereby ensuring that children were unsupported and left fatherless, promoting a negative spiral of intergenerational poverty and crime.

I led “Alternatives to Custody” an NGO in Trinidad, seeking alternative sanctioning options to keep people out of prison. Relationship breakdown often led to femicide. Urban gang warfare filled medieval prisons with young black men. Those leaving prison returned to the community angry and bitter, looking for vulnerable victims to burn off aggression. Alternatives to Custody sought negotiated solutions for crime conflicts with a human development model and organised an international conference in 1998: Transforming the Criminal Justice System through Mediation and Restorative Justice.

Community Mediation

Maura was a keynote speaker and addressed hundreds of people who had never heard of mediation. She introduced and explained its benefits. After that, everyone who had heard her, wanted to be a mediator. The conference was a major success, the Family Mediation Training programme which Maura taught the following week, filled up. Within a year, Trinidad and Tobago’s Community Mediation policy and legislation, programme and regulations were underway and a mainstreamed government service offering family, community, and victim offender mediation, opened in 2000. The service was free to the public, and the NGO was also free to pursue another project. Shortly afterwards, in 2004, Trinidad and Tobago’s Restorative Justice policy was established to transform penal policy. Today, 2021, negotiated restorative approaches continue to advance through the agencies of both criminal and civil justice systems, in Trinidad and Tobago.

Many years later, tens of thousands have used the service. Multiple branches of mediation and negotiation are practiced here. Hundreds of jobs have been created and millions of dollars saved on prison and medical bills; a significant factor in a broken economy.

Distinguishing Features

The distinguishing feature of Maura’s approach to mediation became more apparent in how she taught mediation. She went beyond training into education marked by generosity. Giving away all she had learned from her trailblazing Irish experiences, so that Trinidad could use that foundation, without making initial mistakes. Her legacy flagged shortcuts to a quality service and signalled the bumps and potholes to be steered clear of, en route to agreement.

The quality of her listening went beyond auditory hearing. Bringing deep respectful attention to listening is to provide attentive energy to entrain the speaker’s self-perception. It is to hold a light for clarity and understanding. To facilitate presence by being present to the silent flow of source energy, is a rare encounter of the deeper dimensions of mediation and transformation that will become more common, I believe.

On behalf of Trinidad and Tobago, I thanked Maura for witnessing the deeper emerging future of human dialogue. Those who will never know her name, or hear of her contribution, will appreciate being enriched by her life’s work and offer gratitude that expands good energy on our planet.

Part Three

– Maura’s story resonates through Anna –

Early influences of Maura

I first became aware of the concept of mediation in the 1980s as a civil servant in the Law Division, Department of Justice, Ireland. I was posted on special assignment to the Minister of State for Women’s Affairs and Family Law Reform, Nuala Fennell—a social justice pioneer with an election mandate to deliver a long-awaited, controversial, programme of social reform.

She launched a pilot scheme for a family mediation service that paved the way for separation/divorce legislation. Separating couples could, through this new service, successfully navigate conflicts and find amicable solutions, guided by multi-party mediators. The person appointed to pioneer this ground-breaking service was Maura Wall Murphy; this was my first encounter with the woman who was to become my mentor and friend.

I had the pleasure to work closely with Maura later in 1990/91, in my role as Head of the Courts Division. I learned from her the power of tuning into the unspoken needs of people in conflict, empathising with their situation and empowering them to explore their own solutions. I saw how a skilled mediator could open up new frontiers for conflict resolution and began to awaken to the power of mediation. Great women like Nuala Fennell and Maura Wall Murphy courageously swam against a tide of political and religious opinion, marking a pivotal point in modernising Irish society.

Moving skywards

In 1991, I joined EUROCONTROL, the European Organisation for the Safety of Air Navigation in Brussels. In 2006 my role, as head of social dialogue, was managing industrial relations. Frequently, the kinds of issues that arrived on the social dialogue agenda were unresolved disputes that had escalated upwards from lower levels within the organisation. I tested the idea of informal, early conflict resolution, whereby people could first bring issues to a neutral/impartial mediator. If successful, unresolved individual issues would not necessarily become unresolved collective issues and mediation could also offer cost-effective solutions.

Mediation and European aviation

I sought expert guidance from Maura as my mentor and guide. I trained to become a qualified mediator, first with ACAS, then with the Mediators’ Institute of Ireland and later with the International Mediators’ Institute. I designed the architecture to support the new mediation function at EUROCONTROL to meet the Agency’s emerging needs, enabling mediation to become an integral part of organisational architecture. After a one-year pilot programme, mediation was officially recognised by formal decision of the Director General in December 2007, bringing the EUROCONTROL Mediation Service into existence.

Taking mediation to the world

After leaving EUROCONTROL in 2018, Maura and I kept in touch as she took a keen interest in new ideas in the field of mediation. An inspirational inscription she wrote in 2011 on a book she gifted me – Mediation in Focus: A Celebration of the Family Mediation Service in Ireland – encouraged me to “take mediation to the whole world!”. I have endeavoured to do so through my work as a panel mediator with European Space Agency, as a member of the United Nations Global Mediation Panel, as well as promoting the Mediators’ Green Pledge and acting as study editor for Ireland in the Rebooting Mediation research (soon to be published).

A deep sense of gratitude

Much of my work in mediation has been inspired by Maura. She generously shared her life’s gifts in ways that were deeply enriching, saying to me “Mediation is the most spiritual thing I have ever done”. I also echo her words of deep insight into conflict resolution:

”Trust and empower people to be responsible for their actions. Whoever has the problem also has the solution. It is just a matter of exploring deep enough with patience and time to find meaning and the solution. Always go to the source. They say that everything we do in life is inspired by one of only two emotions – love or fear. Be inspired from love and live without fear.”