March 2025
“Charlie’s dying. Pappa said you can come over to say goodbye if you want.”
It was just three weeks since her daughter had turned 18, and now her voice suddenly sounded so much younger. A higher-pitched voice that used to belong to the carefree child she had been before.
Before what, you might wonder? Well, you told me you wanted to hear a story about conflict. So I will tell you about what happened to a family of four. When I say ‘before’, I mean those peaceful times when this family of four were uncontaminated and blissfully ignorant of what was to sweep over them in 2020. No, not the pandemic. Corona only touched them lightly, fortunately. No, it was a tsunami of a breakup that swept over them and left in its aftermath four broken hearts. A mother who decided she no longer wanted life as it was. Who decided she wanted to leave her marriage. And a father who disagreed.
For almost five years, they had been caught in the aftermath. Stuck. Almost frozen in time.
So, last year, when the mother received the phone call from her daughter with the news of Charlie’s imminent death, she was momentarily stunned into silence. Grief poured through the phone from both ends now, an emotion both of them had experienced more in the last four years than in their entire lifetimes. The mother had reached an age of fifty by now. She had lived long enough to know grief. But her daughter should never have had to experience such grief in her brief lifetime so far.
The grief camouflaged, but not entirely, the underlying disbelief. Not that Charlie was dying, even though this was entirely unexpected, but rather that the eldest daughter could call her mother and invite her over to the house. The house, once their house, where the family of four had lived together. Where he, the father, now lived with both daughters. When they were not living with her, in her new house, down the road. She, affectionately called Mummy, was no longer welcome in his house.
The mother´s name in this story is Nora. Irish, she had moved to Norway twenty-four years ago. She met a Norwegian man when she was twenty-two years of age in Dublin, and at twenty- eight married him in her hometown in Ireland. In 2020, their daughters were ten and thirteen years old, and she made the decision to leave him.
Forty-four years earlier, when she was born, her mother and father had called her Nora, inspired by Henrik Ibsen’s A Doll’s House. Quite strange, the Nora of this story had thought when her own mother shared this with her many years later. The thought had never crossed her mind until after the “tsunami” hit, but her destination was somehow doomed from the start.
Irish, born in Ireland. Named after a Norwegian, ending up falling in love with a Norwegian and moving to Norway as a young adult. But that she was to do exactly what Nora did to Torvald in 1879? Doomed from the start was perhaps a bit of a melodramatic exaggeration, she thought. And yet.
Unlike Ibsen’s Nora, the mother in this story did not feel suffocated by societal and patriarchal control. She could, however, relate to Ibsen’s Nora when it came to a strong desire for freedom and self-discovery outside of her marriage. Something that was never anticipated and never understood by her then Norwegian husband. When Nora walked out of her home in 2020, a peaceful resignation and acceptance of her decision was what she hoped for.
This is not what she got.
And that was when the conflict began. A conflict born out of the end of a relationship and a fundamental disagreement that the relationship should end. A conflict that would, of course, impact the lives of their daughters too. A conflict that lasted for such a long time. Longer than the mother ever would have imagined.
So, when Nora received her daughter’s invitation to see Charlie, indirectly from her ex-husband, it evoked an uncontrollable emotional wave of sadness which she felt deep down in her gut. The same gut in which she used to bury all her feelings until one day she couldn’t anymore. And when her feelings and brutally honest words finally came to the surface, that started the storm that raged for years. No, never, ever, did she think her decision to leave her marriage would instigate such a storm. She was so tired of it.
When her daughter asked her to come over to say goodbye to Charlie, she was taken by surprise. And, of course, deeply saddened by the news about Charlie. A part of her instantaneously shouted no, silently. The thought of facing her ex-husband in her old home, where she had not set foot in five years, was deeply uncomfortable. At the same time, a wave of incredible guilt also washed over her. Guilt because she knew that if she felt that way, her girls would only feel it more. The thought of having their parents in the same room again after all these years could only be dreadfully awkward for both of them.
Despite the no her body was asking for, she said yes. Of course she said yes.
“Dying? What? I am so sorry, sweetie. Yes, I would like to come over” , Nora said to her daughter over the phone. Her daughter started to cry and shared with her mother the events of the past few weeks. “Pappa said you can come over tomorrow night.”
Charlie apparently did not have much time. And that was it. An invitation and an acceptance of an invitation.
Nora leaned back into her blue sofa and let out a sigh that was heard by no one. She was unsure of what would meet her the following evening, but assumed it would be the normal icy front. How could it be anything else? Or, could the warmth radiating from their girls lessen it, for once? How long should she stay for?
Nora thought back on the last five years. Not something she normally allowed herself to do. Thoughts of her optimistic ideals of peaceful cooperation between them post-divorce had proved to be hopelessly unachievable. How her dreams of celebrating the girls’ birthdays together never came true. How she would have liked to go to football matches together. And watch her youngest score an embarrassing amount of goals. She thought about how she had to swallow a thousand camels. Again and again. A Norwegian expression meaning to reluctantly accept something you are strongly against in order to maintain the “peace”.
And then there were all those times when someone, a third party, tried to help them. So many times, the two of them had sat outside an office waiting to be called in. It was almost comical how two people could sit as far as possible from each other in the same room. Each would choose a corner which was the farthest from the other, and preferably not facing each other. With a cold silence that could almost crack the walls holding them there in the first place.
They sat in many waiting rooms together. That was the space they now shared together. The discomfort between them, and within them, was almost unbearable at times. Sometimes she would carefully look over at him when she was sure he was not looking. And despite holding challenging feelings about him, she also felt sadness. For him. A relationship characterised by high conflict. That was what the people behind the office doors used to say about their relationship. And they needed to work on it for the sake of the girls. It was hard to fathom. Them? How could they turn into those parents who couldn’t have a good working relationship post-divorce?
But what happened, perhaps you wonder ? Well, her feelings changed. Nora´s feelings changed. Slowly. Sometimes so slowly she barely noticed herself. An underlying longing for something else grew within her, and the unspoken dissatisfaction with their relationship took years before she finally dared to put words to it. Out loud.
She didn’t want to feel that way. She had married for life. So pushing those feelings back down might cause them to disappear. Another hopeless hope. If she tried really hard?
Later, she understood that is not how emotions work, and what you resist, persists. That’s what the gurus used to say, and that’s exactly how she experienced it too. No, the feelings never left her, but instead grew in intensity. Until one day, like a glacier finally breaking, they exploded and resulted in a torrential cascade of emotional disaster.
The long drive home
She took longer than normal to drive the five miles over to Charlie the following evening. She had no idea what would meet her that night. Who would meet her at the door? Would he? Would they hug? They didn´t hug. She walked slowly up to the front door and took a few deep breaths before she rang the doorbell. Her youngest daughter opened the door almost instantaneously. “I saw your car,” she smiled awkwardly. A hug.
Nora walked into the hallway and noticed different shoes than before. Unfamiliar ones. She tried to hide her nervousness from her daughter, pretending that it was a matter of fact that she was back in the house. But her daughter knew better and walked quickly up the stairs, expecting her mother to follow. How many times had she glided up these stairs before? But now there was no lightness in her step. Halfway up, she noticed that a new picture on the wall had replaced their wedding photos. A picture of a woman in a provocative pose, almost Marilyn Monroe style.
Times do change, she thought.
Her daughter had disappeared by now into the living room, so she quickened her step to hurry upstairs, suddenly feeling very out of place in her old house. She walked into the living room slowly, trying to make her entrance as discreet as possible. And there he sat by the window together with her eldest daughter. Her youngest sat on the floor beside her sister’s feet. They registered her arrival but did not turn around, and yet it did not feel unwelcoming.
An unusual, warm stillness filled the air. She could never remember the room holding such a stillness before.The living room appeared to her in that moment extraordinarily familiar and yet foreign at the same time. Is that how relationships are after a breakup too? Do I know you, or do I not?
She started to make her way over to the window. Through the slightly smeared glass, she caught sight of the view she used to love. That was one of the reasons they had bought the house when their youngest was three years old. The view of the sea. She remembered her mother-in-law (ex?) saying that a sea view can’t make you happy. She had been talking about herself of course, having become a widow in her fifties and living in a beautiful house right by the sea. Nora had never quite agreed with her mother-in-law on this. She felt that their sea view had given her much joy throughout the years. Also through difficult times, like when she lost her own father many years ago.
Since it was late evening in March, the sea was less visible now. Instead, the largeness of the sky and a half-moon formed the backdrop to the scene she was about to encounter. And remember for the rest of her life. They all would.
It was only when she reached them that she saw Charlie.
Completely still, he lay wrapped in a wool blanket in her eldest daughter’s arms. Charlie. Thinner now, his black fur coat seemed far too big for him. Something moved deep inside her. A memory from eleven years earlier, when Charlie lay in the same daughter’s arms after his first arrival into their house. She still had that photo of them greeting her every morning as she made her coffee.
Her daughters loved Charlie with a depth she had never imagined possible for a cat. As the storm raged around them over those years, Charlie became, at times, their lifeline. Yes, a lifeline. Always there for them, his black fur never saturated from absorbing their tears.
She took her eyes away from Charlie for a moment and looked over at him.
“Hello”, he said.
Tears welled in her eyes. She wasn’t sure whether they were for Charlie, for the scene in front of her, or for the almost-welcoming hello she had just received. She understood that he had momentarily laid down his armour, and she could almost recognise the man she had once loved. She felt her shoulders slowly come down, and her breath obediently followed.
They even indulged in a brief exchange about each other’s families. “How is your mother?” “And how is your mother doing?”.
It could have sounded formulaic, but for them, there was nothing ordinary about it. Rather, it was a bit extraordinary. At least that´s how it felt for her. They both responded politely, knowing that four young ears were carefully tuned in and very much on guard. And the longer the mother sat there caressing Charlie’s soft fur, the more they all began to relax in each other’s company.
Not in five years had they sat together like this.
“What is going to happen to Charlie?”, she asked. Charlie would be returned to the vet, after having been admitted there a few days before. So this was his return home to “say” his goodbyes. Perhaps, more accurately, it was to give them some time for their goodbyes to Charlie.
Did she want tea? he offered.” Yes, thank you,” she responded. “Rooibos?”. “Sure, thank you.”
That is what they used to drink together in the evenings. Or was it the mornings? Now, suddenly, she couldn’t remember. How strange. When the tea arrived, the four of them moved away from the window and over to the black leather sofa, where they sat together with Charlie. She noticed the picture they had bought together hanging over the sofa.
She had taken almost nothing from the house when she moved out. Not because she didn’t want some things, but because she didn’t want to ask. Or argue. The Cranberries came to mind. “No need to argue”. No, it was the guilt. That it was her that had brought on all of this. So, she left almost everything. She had taken some cutlery, but she remembered the period following the breakup when her daughters kept asking her about some teaspoons. Whether she had them. Their father wanted them back. She returned all her teaspoons, probably also the ones she had bought herself from IKEA. Anything to keep the peace.
Except it wasn’t peaceful. Until that evening.
The four of them sat together as the father and mother drank tea. And the warmth of the tea seemed to rub off on the icy atmosphere that was now barely felt.
“Do you remember when Charlie hid in the press and we couldn’t find him? Do you remember when Charlie went missing at the cabin and we had to go back up the next day to find him? Do you remember that horrible cat who attacked Charlie that time?
All four of them had different stories to tell of Charlie, and they took turns sharing them. Perhaps all of them wanted to make sure they didn’t talk about anything else. So the stories continued, and they relished the deep pocket of safety and comfort that talking about Charlie provided them. There were even moments of laughter. Actual laughter. And tears.
The mother looked at her girls. And then she looked at him. It had been difficult for her until now to reminisce about times that were gone. When the four of them had shared moments of joy and closeness together. So many of them throughout the years. The divorce and conflict had come solidly in the way. But now she remembered. How it was before. Not quite like this, but a remote resemblance. How it felt. To be part of a family. Her family.
An hour must have passed, and the stories of Charlie started to slow down. She felt it was time. To say goodbye. To leave the house that was once her home. To leave this unusual reunion that had peacefully taken place.
She moved across to Charlie on her daughter’s lap and gently buried her face in his tiny head. “Goodbye, Charlie,” she whispered. She turned to her ex-husband and said, “Thank you.” He nodded, and a half-smile met her as she turned to go downstairs.
She heard her youngest daughter scurry behind her, down the stairs and to the front door. There was nothing left to say. So they hugged. “Bye, sweetie,” she said softly. She opened the front door and walked towards her car.
That was the last time just the four of them sat together in the same room.
After Charlie´s passing
Weeks after saying goodbye to Charlie, her daughter surprised her mother when she told her this.
“You know, Mummy, just a few weeks before Charlie got sick, on my 18th birthday, when I blew out the candles, I made a wish. I wished that the four of us could be reunited again. That we would be able to sit in the same room again.”
Her daughter stopped, and they sat quietly in silence for a couple of minutes. The mother could not believe what she was hearing. How… ? Could Charlie… ? All she wanted to do was to embrace her daughter now. But, she could see that her daughter wanted to say something more. And that she wanted to say it without crying. But her eyes filled with tears.
“I never, ever thought we would be reunited. It was just a silly wish. That it would actually happen. And never in that way. That it would be Charlie, my Charlie, who would sacrifice his life to make my wish come true. But he did. He did this for me. For us, Mummy”. And now, I can let go of any wishes for a different future, where I used to wish that we could all be together again. I know that is not going to happen. And that’s okay. Because that one evening was enough for me. That one evening when we came together and reminisced about all the times with Charlie. That is enough, Mummy.” And then they embraced each other and cried in each other´s arms for the longest time.
The mother was taken aback by what she had heard. And yet, somehow, it made sense. She had never thought about that evening in quite that way before. Perhaps that’s what the mother finally needed to accept too. That this was enough. That short, unexpected and heartfelt reunion. That she could not wish for anything else.
But then, she thought of something else she did wish for.
Today, two years later
Looking back on the conflict, the mother’s view of it had by now changed. Softened. She understood something now. That she couldn´t see before. That there had always been two stories playing out in parallel the whole time during those years of the conflict. And that she and he had been caught up in just one of them.
The surface story. The one that was visible, loud and all-consuming. A story characterised by verbal disagreements, unsuccessful negotiations and painful wins and losses for both of them. That is the story they had been caught up in.
And then there was the story underneath. A story of broken hearts. Of hurt egos. Of extraordinary guilt. Of anger. Disappointment. Of incredible grief – the loss of family life. The loss of a future once held. The story underneath carried unresolved feelings and repressed, unspoken words. Great misunderstandings and endless assumptions. The underlying story was invisible to most. Silent, and yet all-consuming.
She understood this now. Their conversations had been caught up in the surface story and were impossible to resolve because the other story was playing out underneath. The whole time. Feeding upwards into everything above. Why, through all those years, had they not been able to drop below? To talk about the story underneath? To acknowledge and recognise what was really there?
It would have required great courage and vulnerability that perhaps neither of them was capable of then. They were using everything they had just to survive. To get through the days that turned into years. Both had tightly secured their protective steel armour, solidifying the divide and making it almost impossible to reach what lay beneath. They fought their way to get to the end of the surface story. To close that book for good. But they were trying to get through the wrong book.
Perhaps that is what conflict resolution is about? Moving beyond the surface story and finding a way into the heart of the real story underneath. Where feelings can be expressed. Where needs can be articulated. Where hurt can at least be acknowledged.
So, one could not say that their conflict had been resolved. But perhaps dissolved ? Would that make sense to you ? Not disappeared, but dissolved into something smaller. Less “inflamed”. Less potent. Just less.
So, perhaps this story you have just heard now is the third story. The story told now with hindsight. The story told about these two stories that played out. And about a strange synchronicity. A wish made by a girl as she blew out the candles on her 18th birthday. How Charlie, her cat, made sure her wish came through. And, just weeks later following her wish, the family of four were sitting together in the same room again.
One last wish
If you were looking for a happy ending, the narrator of this story was too. Nora, I, could have used my artistic freedom to change the story of my family. An ending where Charlie truly did bring us back together. I could have told you how, after that evening, we met again as a family. For birthdays and other occasions. And how my ex-husband and I stood together at the football pitch once again, cheering for our youngest.
But we didn’t.
Thanks to Charlie, and that evening together, we did however all move into a new phase of our lives. The calm after the raging storm had finally come to subside. A settling. Like muddy waters finally becoming still, the sediment slowly sinking back to the seabed. Each of us gradually found our own degree of peace. And none of us carried the hope anymore that it could be any other way.
They say to never give up hope. At least, cliché remarks often go like that. But perhaps there are some hopes we need to let go of. That previous hope of a “happy family” post-divorce was what had kept me from accepting the reality in front of me. And kept me fighting for something that would never be. For such a long time. It was time to lay down my arms now.
But I do have a different wish. Because I know what we had before. I know what brought our two girls into this world. It was love. There had been so much love. So my wish is this. That my girls experience boundless amounts of love in spite of, or perhaps because of, the conflict that they had to live with. That they trust that love can always find a way. Charlie indeed showed us this. My wish is that my girls dare to choose love. Over and over again.
Yes, that will have to be my last wish, the next time I blow out my birthday candles.
In memory of Charlie